Sep 15, 2011 - I like that he gave praise that the desire for a couple to have their own child is a good one. Some wrongly say that those who use ART are doing so because they think it is their right to have a child. It is the desire that is in their heart, and I agree with the priest that it is a good desire.
Sep 15, 2011 - While it would still lie outside the teachings of the CCC, it seems if only two embryos are created (can the extra eggs and sperm be frozen or is there a need to use those immediately?), and both are implanted, then this would be protecting the embryo's from scientific decisions if they should live, be discarded, or frozen. Is this feasible? Is it necessary to harvest so many eggs, and necessary to initially create so many embryos?
Sep 15, 2011 - I follow the reasoning of the church to protect the embryos. We know the embryo is a human, not when it is ensouled--it maybe at fertilization it maybe after. It does seem wrong for Embryologist to create 5-10, decide which are transferred, which are discarded because they don't make it to blastula as quickly, and which are frozen. It was interesting he mentioned in Italy every embryo created must be implanted.
Post a comment
Local Comments (0)
Youtube Comments (8)
gratiaplena0102 Says:
Mar 13, 2012 - EXCELLENT EXPLANATION WHY IVF IS FLAWED METHOD. VERY LUCRATIVE BUSINESS.
Deadmansparty2002 Says:
Nov 10, 2011 - A flawed argument that is based on values not everyone shares.
11csulli Says:
Sep 15, 2011 - I like that he gave praise that the desire for a couple to have their own child is a good one. Some wrongly say that those who use ART are doing so because they think it is their right to have a child. It is the desire that is in their heart, and I agree with the priest that it is a good desire.
11csulli Says:
Sep 15, 2011 - While it would still lie outside the teachings of the CCC, it seems if only two embryos are created (can the extra eggs and sperm be frozen or is there a need to use those immediately?), and both are implanted, then this would be protecting the embryo's from scientific decisions if they should live, be discarded, or frozen. Is this feasible? Is it necessary to harvest so many eggs, and necessary to initially create so many embryos?
11csulli Says:
Sep 15, 2011 - I follow the reasoning of the church to protect the embryos. We know the embryo is a human, not when it is ensouled--it maybe at fertilization it maybe after. It does seem wrong for Embryologist to create 5-10, decide which are transferred, which are discarded because they don't make it to blastula as quickly, and which are frozen. It was interesting he mentioned in Italy every embryo created must be implanted.